Skip to main content

Werth Trade Would Not Equal Surrender


Months ago a source close to the team (some said Milt Thompson) disclosed that the Phillies were very close to reaching a contract extension with outfielder Jayson Werth. Later reports stated that the Phillies would lock Werth up by the All-star Break. Common sense also told the public that if neither of those were the case, the Phillies could likely deal Werth soon after the Break, as the non-waiver trading deadline comes up quickly, at the end of July.

When Chase Utley's thumb diagnosis (surgery, likely to miss 8 weeks while recovering) was announced to the world, some phans were ready to tap out for the season and swiftly suggested the Phillies deal Werth to get what they could for him, as July and the realization of the Phillies not coming to terms with Werth were drawing near.

Other folks began to equate a possible trade of Werth with the Phillies waving a white flag this season. That does not have to be the case, especially with baseball's top prospect Domonic Brown waiting in the wings to fill any void that Werth would leave.

Brown, a corner outfielder, is tearing up minor league pitching this year (.326 avg, 19 HR, 59 RBI, 14 steals, .999 OPS in 80 games between Double A and Triple A this season) and is widely regarded as a blue chip prospect. Brown projects to put up the same type of 20 HR/20 steal production that Werth has become best known for.

If the Phillies sent Werth away and got a proven ace pitcher in return, that addition to the starting rotation could certainly outweigh any downgrade in the outfield, especially if Brown can contribute right away. While the Phillies' offense has seemed to be the problem, they've actually outscored their entire division in less games played. Improved pitching is needed to keep the team closer in games, as the Phillies rank 8th in the league (4th in the division) in starting pitcher ERA at 4.02.

Recent trade rumors involving Werth include the following...
-Werth in a complex deal that might include more pieces to Boston for righty hurler Clay Buchholz (2.45 ERA in 15 starts this season), who is currently sidelined with a hamstring issue.
-Werth to the Yankees for Javier Vazquez (4.21 ERA in 403 Major League games), following a potential Cliff Lee to New York trade.

Another manner in which the Phillies could deal Werth and improve the squad could be if the Phils took part in a 3-way deal, where they send Werth to Team X (possibly Boston), who, in turn, sends
prospects to Team Y. Team Y could then send an A-list pitcher (possibly Dan Haren who has a 3.68 ERA in 214 career ML games, or Roy Oswalt who has a 3.08 ERA in 18 starts this season) to the Phils, who would hopefully receive a nice jolt from the influx of new talent and not become Team Zzzzz.

____________________________


Follow PhoulBallz.com on Twitter HERE.

Comments

Gonzo Undead said…
Trade Werth, and the season is over. In over 125 years, the Phils have made the playoffs about 15 times. I am NOT ready to give up on the season. I don't care what we would get back for Werth. We're not GM's. I don't give a fuck about next year. I want to win NOW.

Popular posts from this blog

Prospect Nation 2012: #1 RHP Trevor May

With a massively impressive campaign in 2011 for the Class A Advanced Clearwater Threshers, right-handed starting pitcher Trevor May locked down his spot as Philadelphia's top prospect and is on the fast track toward the big leagues. He is the reigning Paul Owens Award winner, given to the top pitcher and player in the Phillies' developmental system each year. In 27 starts with the Threshers in 2011, May posted a 10-8 record with a 3.63 ERA, while striking out a Florida State League leading 208 batters in 151 1/3 innings. He also held opposing hitters to a .221 average. The Phillies' 4th round draft pick from 2008, May earned the win in the 50th annual Florida State League All-Star Game at Bright House Field last year. He also was twice named FSL Pitcher of the Week and earned Phillies Minor League Pitcher of the Month honors for June. After signing with Philadelphia, May helped lead the rookie level Gulf Coast League Phillies to a championship in 2008. In 5 regular ...

PhoulBallz Interview: RHP Prospect Brody Colvin

Recently, right-handed pitcher Brody Colvin was promoted from Class A Advanced Clearwater to Double-A Reading. Prior to the 2012 season, Colvin, who turns 22-years-old on Tuesday, was ranked as PhilliesNation's 6th best prospect . This season, following some ups and downs, it's unclear where Colvin will rank next preseason. Earlier this year, Colvin, a Louisiana native, was removed from Clearwater's starting rotation and moved to the bullpen to relax and improve his mental approach. He did so and returned to starting after a brief time. Through his first two outings with the R-Phils, the 7th round draft choice from 2009 posted a 1-0 record while allowing five earned runs in 11 innings (4.09 ERA). In his last start on Saturday, however, Colvin allowed eight earned runs in 2 2/3 innings pitched in a loss to New Britain. In a recent interview with Brody, he spoke about the transition moving to the Eastern League, his brief bullpen stint, physical concerns from last season...

Phillies look-alikes, Part 1

The Phillies are World Series Champions and, thus, are world wide celebrities. This recognition isn't enough, I tell you. Some of the champs could very well be confused with other major celebrities around the globe...or at least around my house. Let's dig in... Two look-alikes in particular have been widely discussed. Geoff Jenkins even made a sign on the table covering at his autograph station at last year's Phillies Phestival that he is not Brett Favre or phormer Phillie Randy Wolf. ------------------------------------------------------- Jayson Werth may be on his way to Wrestlemania. Jay-Dub is aware that he resembles Heavyweight wrestling champion Adam "Edge" Copeland. Are you? -------------------------------------------- Carlos Ruiz's fame was boosted by TBS during the playoffs, but he might be ready for his own Comedy Central sketch show, as he looks very much like Carlos Mencia. Dee dee dee! -------------------------------------------------- And whi...