Skip to main content

PhoulBallz Roundtable: Thome's Place in History

On Monday night, the Minnesota Twins' designated hitter Jim Thome mashed a homerun at the Major League level for the 600th time, becoming only the eighth man ever to do so.

Over what has been beyond an impressive 20-year big league career, Thome has become one of the game's most renowned sluggers, while playing for five different teams. Somehow, though, what would previously have screamed the biggest story in sports, when heavy hitters of the past reached landmarks or chased records, has now had its volume turned way down as one of the game's most liked individuals, Thome, approached the 600 HR plateau.

That lack of great buzz could make some wonder why Thome's approach toward the beastly breakthrough wasn't afforded as much attention as previous baseball milestone's. To discuss those concerns and to address Thome's legend specifically, I asked some friends of this site to offer their thoughts.

-Where does Jim Thome rank among the game's all-time best homerun hitters?

Former Phillies beat reporter Mike Olshin...
Jim Thome is a throwback player, someone who would have been a slugger in any era. He just seems like he belonged in the 50's or 60's, or at least the way we romanticized baseball back then.

Co-host of Just a Bit Outside on 97.3 ESPN in Atlantic City and 105.7 The Hawk, Joe Giglio...
Where does Thome rank all time? As one of its best sluggers. He played in an era where on base percentage was valued and batting average lost appeal. The knock on him is that he was a totally one-dimensional player, but as a hitter? There were few guys with more power. Historically? He's the modern day Reggie Jackson, except for that whole October thing. writer Kieran Carobine...
To hit 600 homeruns across two leagues says something about the hitting of Thome. He has been a guy who has gone from role player to DH without skipping a beat. The greatest thing about Thome is that he has done all this without having his name mentioned with performance enhancing drugs. Thome is a hitter's hitter. Unlike Matt Stairs, who admittedly tried to crush a homer every time, Thome approached the plate to hit. And lucky for him, it left the yard a couple or 600 times.

Yours truly, Jay Floyd, of various online baseball outlets...
Unfortunately, this is of great concern to me. While the few news features I've seen regarding Thome's 600th homerun have, in some way, asserted that he is one of the game's most liked stars, the limited attention to this milestone, compared to landmarks reached in recent years, genuinely has me concerned about Thome's importance in many folks' minds. Barry Bonds was widely known to be an objectionable figure, and he got tremendous amounts of attention as he chased the single season and all-time homerun records over the past decade. Nice guys finish last?

-Does the 600 HR milestone still mean the same as it once did?

I think 600 HR means a great deal even now. It says something about longevity and continued excellence. A lot of the "steroids stars" burned out and didn't have the career milestone that 600 signifies. I guess you can say 600 is the new 500.

Ballpark E-guides
author Kurt Smith...
The prevailing sentiment regarding Thome’s home run total doesn’t appear to be earthshaking, because 600 home runs doesn’t seem like a big deal anymore. But it is. Only seven other players in history have accomplished it. The lack of enthusiasm this time around is a reflection of the times; and the feeling that at least three of the last four players to reach 600 home runs did not come by that total in the most honest of ways.

Lifelong baseball fan and friend of this site, Jackson Weihl...
I think that 600 means less today than it has in the past. I do think that the 600 club is more relevant than the 500 club. I think that Thome has had a legitimate career never being suspected or named by anyone. To my knowledge he wasn't named on the congressional report, by Canseco or by anyone else. He's been consistent, hasn't had an odd growth spurt or pattern and hasn't broken down the way a PED user likely would. He has been injured a considerable amount in recent years, but not with typical PED tainted injuries.

Exactly as Olshin said, in the theme of Jay-Z's "30's the new 20", in Major League Baseball these days, 600 HR is the new 500 HR. Growing up, I owned a video, hosted by Bob Costas and Mickey Mantle, which reviewed the greatest sluggers ever- The 500 Homerun Club. At that time, it was an extremely exclusive circle, with just 14 members. Since Phillies Hall of Famer Mike Schmidt joined that group in 1987, another 11 members have followed. The previously elite clique is now getting too easy to crack. This next level achievement by Thome is massive and is worthy of a great amount of attention.

-Is Thome's place in history affected by the era in which he played?

There will always be people who de-emphasize longball numbers in the 90's and 00's. But Thome was a great, consistent slugger when compared within his own era. And that's probably the fairest way to do it.

I believe his place in history is affected both positively and negatively by the era he played in. On the one hand, milestone numbers, especially with the long ball, are not paid the attention or reverence they once were because of steroids. On the other, the lack of steroid rumors or positive tests surrounding him make him one of the likable guys.

The steroid era has, unfortunately, cast a shadow of doubt over all of baseball’s power totals—one of an infinite number of compelling reasons for their prohibition. Barry Bonds broke two of baseball’s unbreakable records, and fans yawned, knowing just by the size of his head that he was aided by chemicals. This was followed by A-Rod and Sammy Sosa passing the 600 mark, both of whom were credibly accused and don’t have much clout in the trustworthiness category; A-Rod just because he’s A-Rod, and Sosa because he had been busted with a corked bat in the past.

But I’m not going to get into a semantic debate about it here. Thome, to my knowledge anyway, has never been credibly accused of PED use, nor has he been involved in any personal scandals. For all of his achievements on the field, at least publicly anyway, Thome also has an image of being a decent guy off of it. I don’t know him personally obviously, and I was saddened to learn Kirby Puckett wasn’t such a wonderful human after all.

But for now Thome not only deserves the benefit of the doubt, he deserves accolades for an incredible achievement that only seven players in history have accomplished, even with the help of drugs.

I think has place in history will be lessened by the poor choices by some of his peers, but for me he is one of the best real power hitters of our time and just country strong. He was also a really good well rounded hitter in Cleveland, and beyond, for most of his career, in terms of average for a true power hitter. He absolutely is a Hall of Famer. The only thing that could keep him from being a first ballot HOF'er is the real lack of position.

It seems like the performance enhancing drug accusations of others have affected the way fans of baseball regard power totals. There's probably not much else to blame when, by comparison, Derek Jeter being the 28th man to do something (reaching 3,000 career hits earlier this season) gets wildly greater amounts more fanfare than Thome does, being the eighth player ever to accomplish a similarly longevity dependent feat.

-Other thoughts
I rooted for Jim Thome in his pursuit of 600 home runs. He has been one of the most consistent, prolific and likable baseball players over the last 20 years. His "country power" and clean perception have elevated him in fans mind, and rightfully so. Aside from Ken Griffey, we haven't seen a player get to 600 homers without a cloud of performance enhancing drugs in a long time.


Image- AP

You can follow PhoulBallz on Twitter by clicking HERE.

You can also connect with PhoulBallz on Facebook by clicking HERE.


Popular posts from this blog

Frosty Phillies Favorites: 2021 Edition w/ DJ Stewart

Season's greetings to all of you! It's that time of the year to celebrate and enjoy the holiday season. Every year at Christmas time, I survey a group of Phillies prospects about what they get excited for during the holidays.  This year, we focus on just one up and coming player, corner infielder DJ Stewart. The 22-year-old righty batter had a solid season in 2021. In 94 games combined with Class A Clearwater and Class A Advanced Jersey Shore, Stewart notched a .265 batting average with 14 home runs, 42 RBI and five stolen bases.  Recently, I talked with DJ to gain his feedback on all of his holiday favorites. Read ahead for that interview... -What's your favorite Christmas movie? My favorite is This Christmas.  My Mother and I would watch it together every Christmas, so it just stuck with me. -What is your favorite Christmas song and which version is best? This Christmas by Chris Brown.  It's the final song of my favorite Christmas movie. -What's your favorit

Biddle slated to make Reading return on Saturday

Jesse Biddle, image- Jay Floyd After a miserable stretch of starts in June, lefty pitcher Jesse Biddle was placed on Double-A Reading's temporary inactive list. On Saturday, he'll make his long awaited return to the FirstEnergy Stadium mound when he starts the first game of the Fightins' scheduled double header against Binghamton. The 22-year-old posted a 0-4 record with a 12.64 ERA in four June starts. It was clear that there was something quite wrong with Biddle, who had missed a start in late May after being pelted with hail and suffering a concussion. A mixture of feelings including confusion and anger were firmly settling in while Biddle's efforts on the mound were not. The Phils saw a need for the Philadelphia native and Germantown Friends School product to take a break. Exams discovered lasting impact on Biddle stemming from the concussion and time off was required. "For me it was an important time not only to take a mental break and to go down

Franco making case for September call up

Maikel Franco, image- Jay Floyd While the minor league season begins to wind down, Lehigh Valley third baseman Maikel Franco continues to go full throttle. As the IronPigs kicked off their final home stand of the season on Saturday with a double header against the division rival Syracuse Chiefs, Franco, who is hoping his season continues on beyond the final day on the regular season calendar, which is Labor Day, September 1st, continued to display his improved offensive efforts going 6-for-7 with two home runs combined in two games while recording a cycle in the night cap. The feat was certainly quite an achievement, but possibly more impressive because it was accomplished in just six offensive innings for the winning home club in game 2, as minor league double headers are slated as seven-inning contests. Franco, who turns 22 years old this week, struggled through the early part of his first Triple-A season, ending June with a .202 batting average and just 28 extra-base hits