Skip to main content

Rotation Altercation

Have a look over these following descriptions of two pitching rotations and see which is preferable.

Option A-
#1 starter- 25-year-old lefty who is fresh off one of the best postseason runs in baseball history and won the MVP award for both the League Championship Series and the World Series.
#2 starter- 7 year veteran former top draft pick, with 3 winning seasons as a starter and a 21 save season as a reliever.
#3 starter- A 28-year-old 5 year veteran right-hander with a career .525 winning percentage and a 4.24 ERA.
#4 starter- A veteran 46-year-old who should win his 250th game during the season and just signed a 2 year contract.
#5 starter- A 35-year-old journeyman who hasn't seen success as a starter in any of his previous six seasons.

Option B-
#1 starter- 6 time all-star, Cy Young Award winner, 11 year veteran regarded as one of the top pitchers in the sport with a career win percentage over .660.
#2 starter- 26-year-old lefty pitcher who is one year removed from being the defending NLCS MVP and the World Series MVP.
#3 starter- A 29-year-old 6 year veteran right-hander with a career .538 win percentage, and a 4.21 ERA.
#4 starter- A young lefty defending runner up to the NL Rookie of the Year Award who threw 3 complete games and had a 2.93 ERA in the previous season.
#5 starter- (One of two...) Veteran 47-year-old lefty recovering from off-season surgery with 250+ career wins OR a 25-year-old righty with 24 career Major League wins.

It seems as though the preferred choice would be option B, and that is good, because that is the option that represents the Phillies' 2010 pitching rotation. Option A, of course, represents the Phillies' rotation from the start of 2009.


With so much regret and second guessing surrounding the trade that sent Cliff Lee to Seattle, there's a considerable amount of underappreciation going on regarding the Phillies' existing pitching starters.

While the current group of starting pitchers could have been better than it is, the starting 5 is still better than it was. Buhlee' dat!

Roy Halladay is an upgrade over Cole Hamels in the #1 spot. Cole Hamels is certainly an improvement over Myers in 2nd spot. Joe Blanton holds onto the #3 spot and could be better, and definitely should not be any worse after improving his career statistics just a tad last season. As for the 4th starter, who would argue that the confidence level with "Jay" Happ filling that role is far greater this time around when reflecting on Jamie Moyer in that spot last year?

With the 5th starter spot seemingly up for grabs, like it was last year at this time, Kyle Kendrick should be a better option than Chan Ho Park. If Jamie Moyer is healthy and is named the 5th starter, many phans would feel more comfortable calling a 250 game winner, with something (that he's healthy or that he deserves the big salary he will earn this season) to prove, a step up from Chan Ho Park in that role.

It's not wrong to ponder what could have been for the Phillies. However, it is wrong to ignore what the team has...and that's a strong, improved rotation that will lead them back to the postseason.

-------------------------

Follow PhoulBallz.com on Twitter HERE!


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Frosty Phillies Favorites: 2021 Edition w/ DJ Stewart

Season's greetings to all of you! It's that time of the year to celebrate and enjoy the holiday season. Every year at Christmas time, I survey a group of Phillies prospects about what they get excited for during the holidays.  This year, we focus on just one up and coming player, corner infielder DJ Stewart. The 22-year-old righty batter had a solid season in 2021. In 94 games combined with Class A Clearwater and Class A Advanced Jersey Shore, Stewart notched a .265 batting average with 14 home runs, 42 RBI and five stolen bases.  Recently, I talked with DJ to gain his feedback on all of his holiday favorites. Read ahead for that interview... -What's your favorite Christmas movie? My favorite is This Christmas.  My Mother and I would watch it together every Christmas, so it just stuck with me. -What is your favorite Christmas song and which version is best? This Christmas by Chris Brown.  It's the final song of my favorite Christmas movie. -What's your favorit

Franco making case for September call up

Maikel Franco, image- Jay Floyd While the minor league season begins to wind down, Lehigh Valley third baseman Maikel Franco continues to go full throttle. As the IronPigs kicked off their final home stand of the season on Saturday with a double header against the division rival Syracuse Chiefs, Franco, who is hoping his season continues on beyond the final day on the regular season calendar, which is Labor Day, September 1st, continued to display his improved offensive efforts going 6-for-7 with two home runs combined in two games while recording a cycle in the night cap. The feat was certainly quite an achievement, but possibly more impressive because it was accomplished in just six offensive innings for the winning home club in game 2, as minor league double headers are slated as seven-inning contests. Franco, who turns 22 years old this week, struggled through the early part of his first Triple-A season, ending June with a .202 batting average and just 28 extra-base hits

Biddle slated to make Reading return on Saturday

Jesse Biddle, image- Jay Floyd After a miserable stretch of starts in June, lefty pitcher Jesse Biddle was placed on Double-A Reading's temporary inactive list. On Saturday, he'll make his long awaited return to the FirstEnergy Stadium mound when he starts the first game of the Fightins' scheduled double header against Binghamton. The 22-year-old posted a 0-4 record with a 12.64 ERA in four June starts. It was clear that there was something quite wrong with Biddle, who had missed a start in late May after being pelted with hail and suffering a concussion. A mixture of feelings including confusion and anger were firmly settling in while Biddle's efforts on the mound were not. The Phils saw a need for the Philadelphia native and Germantown Friends School product to take a break. Exams discovered lasting impact on Biddle stemming from the concussion and time off was required. "For me it was an important time not only to take a mental break and to go down