Skip to main content

Schmidt vs. Howard


The latest issue, dated February 2nd, of the Sporting News features a cover story on Phillies slugger Ryan Howard. In the issue, Ken Bradley asked Hall of Fame third baseman Mike Schmidt who would hit more homers, Howard or Schmidt, in Schmidt's choice of an era. Old #20 had this to say about choosing himself...


This era and the stadiums they play in today- and it's not a
chip-on-the-shoulder thing or sour grapes by me- it's probably about a 10-a-year
difference. Slicing the ball to the opposite field and having it go out of
the ballpark didn't happen very often when I played. I flew out to the
opposite-field warning track maybe 50 times a year, and 10 of those would go out
of the park now. (But) we'd be very similar. In terms of being able
to go 50-plus, 60-plus, he might have a little bit more of that kind of ability,
but our numbers would probably average somewhere in the 40's on a regular basis.
Please chime in with your thoughts on this matter in the comments section and vote in the poll. Who would be there better power hitter?

In the issue, Howard comments safely on sports phans in Philadelphia, stating...
They get on you because they want you to do well.

Asked about coming up in the Phils minor league system with Jim Thome blocking his path to the majors, Ryan said...
I remember when he signed, I was like, 'Yeah! Wow! We got Jim Thome!' That was the fan in me coming out. But then the minor
leaguer in me was like, "Damn. We just signed Jim Thome."

Howard was also asked about what might concern him more, his batting average or his high strike out totals. He said...
Overall , it's just hits. Really and truthfully, the strikeouts are part of the game. I just happen to do it a little more than somebody else who may ground out. I think it's kind of overrated. I had, what, 199
strikeouts last year? And I still led the major leagues in homeruns and
RBI's. So, I mean, whoop-de-whoop.

The magazine also features a sidebar with Shane Victorino, who says we don't know Ryan Howard like he knows Ryan Howard (whoop-de-whoop indeed!) and a delicious looking Subway ad featuring Ryan. You can pick up the issue on news stands in the coming days.

Comments

GM-Carson said…
Great post!

I love Schmitty, but Howard is raw power, so I give Ryan the upperhand. However, Schmidt is bar far the superior player.
IRONPIGPEN said…
Agreed. Howard superior power. Schmidt superior baseball player. People forget glove in the field with Schmidt alot I believe. No disrespect to Howard. Proper respect to Schmidt, I believe.
mark evans said…
Great post Mister B.
I love that the HOFer takes his rightful honor and declares that he'd have been more prolific in today's parks (a solid fact- yes number twenty would've clocked at least ten more dingers per year). And in the same breath he credits Ryno for being more of a pure power hitter.
It's too early to assume number six will be a Hall of Famer, Mr. Howard needs to put up a few more years of gawdy numbers before he can stand shoulder to shoulder with Mike.

Aint it great to have both of em in Phils lore!

Popular posts from this blog

Rappers in Phillies Caps

Weekend greetings to you phine pholks out there. Today's post features pictures of rappers wearing Phillies caps. Why rappers in Phillies caps, you ask? Because... Any other questions? We will start things off properly by going with a highly recognizable hip hop star. 50 Cent stays constantly relavant by consistantly creating radio friendly material to help sell (G) units, while he "keeps it real" by still rapping about the thug life he lived before becoming the 2nd highest earning black entertainer in America. 50 is seen here in a recent interview rocking a throw-back Phillies cap. Next up we'll use a throw-back screen cap from what may be the very first major appearance by a rapper wearing Phillies gear. Chuck D, of legendary rap group Public Enemy, wore a Phillies cap in the music video for rap anthem Fight The Power in 1989. The song was the lead single from the soundtrack for Spike Lee's film Do The Right Thing . Next up we'll go with some home grown tal...

Ring-a-ling

This week I heard old news about how when the Indianapolis Colts won the Super Bowl, they gave former Colt Edgerrin James a championship ring. "Edge" had been a Colt for seven years, and even though he was gone when they won the big one, the team and the coaching staff felt as though James had contributed in building the team that won it all, so they awarded him a ring. This got me wondering which people, in an extended Phillies phamily , would be deserving of a 2008 World Series Champions ring. I heard an interview with Mike Schmidt, in the days that followed the Series, and when asked if he thought he'd get a ring, he said, "They have my (ring) size." Schmidt, the Hall of Fame thirdbaseman , was a long time Phillie, a one time coach of the single-A Clearwater Threshers (where he managed World Series MVP Cole Hamels ) and appears as a guest hitting instructor in Phillies spring training every year. With all those things in mind, of course Mike Schmidt shou...

All in the Family

22-year-old pitching prospect Nick Hernandez's father helps him stay fit during the off-season Phillies pitching prospect Nick Hernandez spent much of the 2010 regular season on the disabled list with an injury to his throwing shoulder. The 6'4", 215 pound lefty, who was named a mid-season South Atlantic League all-star with the Class A Lakewood BlueClaws, attempted comebacks twice during the season, making rehab outings for the rookie level Gulf Coast League Phillies, but experienced setbacks that curtailed his return to the mound and kept him from helping his teammates lock down a second consecutive league championship for Lakewood. In 8 starts with the BlueClaws last season, the 12th round draft pick from 2009 posted a 3-1 record with a 1.61 ERA and averaged 7 innings per start. Hernandez's strength is throwing a lot of strikes and he owes some of his success to his father, also named Nick (Dad's full first name is spelled Nicolas, while son's name is spell...